Peeing on Corpses, What's So Wrong with That?

thebridge's picture

Four Marines peeing on the dead bodies of their enemies. What's so wrong with that?

Oh yes. Everything.

Sure, war is hell and niceties play by different rules, but there are things to consider. Sure, these were enemies of our country, people who believe in killing as many of us as possible. They may deserve no respect at all, but--

Wouldn’t you be disgusted if the opposite happened? Aren’t we wracked with revulsion and horror seeing what has happened to deceased U.S. soldiers? I won’t go into detail, because they are quite gruesome.

Let’s not give ‘em any more reason to hurt us. We need to be more culturally sensitive and to work towards peaceful resolution.

Supposedly the War on Terror is over. Well, not exactly, especially since the violence seemed to escalate after that announcement. After hearing about the disgusting lack of respect these Marines showed these dead men, I could only figure this would incite more violence.

This quote from this article sums it up for me: “Although there were no reports of disturbances or protests tied to the video on Friday, the Islamic day of rest, the widespread anger over it illustrated how little success the United States has had in improving its standing in the eyes of many Afghans, despite spending hundreds of millions of dollars on many programs, from building schools to financing pro-Western news media outlets.”

There’s an inherent problem in the culture when those who’s job it is to protect us and promote freedom are pulling such stunts. It’s my belief that one person can make a difference, create a change in the world. Here’s four people making a difference that will surely have negative results.

These four guys probably had this mentality in high school: “Let’s nuke ‘em! Who cares?” I’ve had classmates in high school who made that exact statement. It’s that closed-minded, lazy, masculine show of force that creates more problems than it solves.

I say we need to be the better person here. If we can show ever our enemies that we can do that, perhaps they won’t see us as so evil anymore. 

Addendum: 

Please note that I'm not harboring resentment towards the military or marines in general. What I wish to point out is that the poor choices of a few individuals make everyone look bad, perhaps even the entirety of the American people in the eyes of a foreign nation. There are other men and women in the line of duty who do their jobs and do them right, working towards promoting our freedom and put a stop to terrorism. I just wish that these four Marines in question could have thought a little about the repercussions of their actions before they did what they did. 

Category Tags: 

Comments

5

There’s an inherent problem in the culture when those who’s job it is to protect us and promote freedom are pulling such stunts.

I think it is pretty broad to condemn the culture of the Marine Corps which is built around courage, self-sacrifice, honor and respect based on the very isolated and definitely stupid and indefensible actions of a very few of its members. War is hell but for you to imply that this one rare case defines the culture of the Marine Corps is way off base. It is fine to condemn the individuals but your blog goes a lot farther than that.

These guys are probably, as you say, gungho types with high school educations. That would probably be true for most of our military personnel below the officer grade. Yet we have been at war for more than a decade now and you can count these types of unfortunate incidents on your fingers. Our military is extremely professional. Compare this to some of the nasty incidents that went on during Viet Nam like whole innocent villages being wiped out or compare it to some of the behavior by our enemy like using women, children and mentally challenged people as suicide bombers to blow up innocent civilians and our military looks very good. War is hell and unfortunate stuff happens but we have probably fielded the most disciplined and professional military in the history of the world.

These guys may be just high school educated. But ask yourself this? Would you rather have your daughter marry the average marine enlisted man or the average college educated filthy lice-ridden Occupy Wall Street type who was too lazy to go get a job and wants his college debts forgiven and everything handed to him/her free? For me the answer is clear. I want the guy with the courage and the honor to put his life in harms way to serve his country.

Are you going to be one of the ones spitting on our troops when they come home? This blog comes pretty close. They deserve better than this type of condemnation. They have had a rough go. My son-in-law is on his second deployment. First to Iraq and currently in Afghanistan. Some of these guys are on their third and fourth deployments. They deserve some praise and support because it is very tough being over there.

It is fine and appropriate to condemn these individuals but to extend that to a general condemnation of our very professional military is just wrong.

thebridge's picture

I apologize for this blog appearing to be a general condemnation on the Marines or any other branch of the military. What I meant to point out what the thoughtless decisions of a few make serious problems for all involved. I am not the type of person to spit on the troops and certainly don't feel sympathy for those who do. They were there for a reason, and I'm just pointing out that a few select soldiers have cast a negative light on the rest. It's the same with any given population. A few college students doing a crazy hazing stunt will make a university look bad. A tuba player out of step can make the whole section in the marching band look bad.

I'm sorry this blog came across the way it did and I am making the appropriate changes.

Bridge, I believe you.  You've never seemed to be that type of person.  I probably over-react when I see anybody get critical of the military.

It has been a very long war and it is not clear to me that the end is insight.  There is also other stuff going on that have made the last few years tough.   People are getting frustrated and it is not surprising to me that this frustration manifests itself as criticism.  Of all the people who might deserve criticism in this country, our military has done their done their jobs selflessly and competently at a lot of personal cost and are probably at the absolute bottom of the list of people deserving criticism or blame.

If the deceased were greatest scum, killing  them done the world greatest justice.  However,  if after, I urinate on the deceased, this makes me, the greatest living scum.  This says a lot about, one's morals.

thebridge's picture

It's basically an issue of "don't lower yourself to your enemy's level" and what morally makes a better person.